When another driver lies about a car accident, your rights, your money, and your future are on the line. If you don’t act fast, their lies can become the “official” version of the crash. Those lies can impact how fault is assigned. That means you could end up blamed for an accident you didn’t cause—and left with medical bills, lost wages, and a wrecked car.
If you suspect the other driver is lying, you need an attorney who won’t let them get away with it.
At Lloyd Miller Law Group in Chicago, we’ve won countless cases where the truth was buried under false police statements, fabricated stories, and insurance company pressure. Call 773-838-8100.
Table of Contents
Why Drivers Lie After a Car Accident
After a crash, some drivers lie out of fear. Some lie to protect their driving record. Others lie simply because they think they can get away with it. Common reasons drivers in Chicago lie about accidents include:
Financial Protection
- Avoiding higher insurance premiums that could last for years
- Preventing deductible increases or policy cancellations
- Dodging expensive repair costs or medical bills
Legal Consequences
- Hiding that they were speeding, distracted, or drunk
- Avoiding traffic tickets or criminal charges
- Protecting their driving record or CDL license
Strategic Deception
- Blaming the victim to dodge liability entirely
- Taking advantage of confused or injured victims
In Illinois, we’ve seen drivers falsify accident reports, deny running red lights, and even invent phantom road hazards. The good news? Lies can be proven false with the right evidence.
What Happens If the Driver Lies About the Car Accident?
When a driver lies about the car accident, it can impact nearly every part of your case.
- Insurance Investigations – Adjusters may side with the liar if you don’t provide strong counter-evidence.
- Police Reports – If the officer writes down their false story, it can bias the record.
- Fault Determination – In Illinois, liability directly affects how much compensation you receive.
- Civil Lawsuits – If the lie holds up, you could be wrongly blamed in court.
This is why documenting the scene immediately, getting medical attention, and hiring an experienced Chicago car accident lawyer is crucial.
Evidence That Exposes the Lies
At Lloyd Miller Law Group, we don’t rely on “he said, she said.” We build cases on hard evidence. This includes:
Video Evidence
- Police bodycam and dashcam footage
- Traffic and intersection surveillance cameras
- Security cameras from nearby businesses
- Dashboard cameras from vehicles
Digital Evidence
- Black box (EDR) data from vehicles
- Cell phone records showing distraction
- GPS tracking data
- Text message timestamps
Expert Analysis
- Eyewitness testimony
- Accident reconstruction experts
- Medical expert testimony about injury patterns
Even when the other driver lies under oath, these types of evidence can prove the truth.
Illinois Law on Fault and Lies in Car Accidents
Illinois uses modified comparative negligence in car accident cases. If the other driver lies and manages to pin more than 50% of the fault on you, you lose your right to compensation. Even if you’re found partially at fault, your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault.
How It Works:
- 0-50% at fault: You can recover damages, reduced by your fault percentage
- 51-100% at fault: You recover nothing
That means a lie isn’t just an annoyance. It could cost you your entire case. Our attorneys know how to dismantle false stories before they stick.
Chicago Drivers and False Accident Claims
Car accidents are a daily reality in Chicago, from the Dan Ryan Expressway to Lake Shore Drive. With thousands of crashes each year, dishonest drivers often try to twist the facts to protect themselves. In fact, according to the Illinois Department of Transportation’s 2023 crash data, Cook County saw over 30% of all crashes in Illinois, and disputes over fault are among the most common issues after these wrecks.
That means if you’re in a Chicago crash, there’s a real risk the other driver may lie about how it happened. They might deny running a red light in Cicero, claim you rear-ended them downtown, or insist you were speeding near O’Hare. Knowing how to spot and fight these lies is critical to winning your claim.
The Timeline of a Car Accident Case When Lies Are Involved
When another driver lies, every stage of your case gets harder, but not impossible to win. Here’s what usually happens:
At the Scene – The other driver may downplay their role, deny traffic violations, or even blame you outright. If their statement makes it into the police report uncontested, it could set the tone for the entire case.
Police Report Stage – Officers must make quick judgments. If the other driver sounds convincing, and you don’t have evidence on hand, the official report may lean in their favor. That’s why photographs, witnesses, and your own clear statement are essential.
Insurance Claim – Insurance adjusters are trained to save money, not find truth. If the other driver lies, and you can’t immediately disprove it, insurers will happily use their version to deny or reduce your payout.
Lawsuit and Trial – Lies become perjury when repeated under oath, but exposing them takes strategy. Through discovery, subpoenas, and cross-examination, your lawyer can dismantle false testimony and present hard evidence to the judge or jury.
At Lloyd Miller Law Group, we understand how lies evolve through each stage of the process. That’s why we go on the offensive immediately to keep the truth front and center.
What to Do if the Other Driver Lies About the Car Accident
- Call the Police Immediately – Always file a report, even for minor accidents.
- Document Everything – Take photos of the scene, vehicles, injuries, and traffic signs.
- Get Witness Info – Independent eyewitnesses are powerful against lies.
- Seek Medical Attention – Creates a record of your injuries.
- Contact Lloyd Miller Law Group – We cut through lies with facts, evidence, and aggressive legal action.
The High Cost of Letting Lies Stand
If you think a lie will “work itself out,” think again. Failing to fight back can cost you:
- Your settlement – Illinois’ comparative negligence law means a single lie could strip you of compensation entirely.
- Your record – If you’re wrongly found at fault, your driving history and insurance premiums take a permanent hit.
- Your credibility – Once the other driver’s story becomes “fact,” undoing it is nearly impossible without strong legal action.
- Your financial future – Without compensation, you’re left paying medical bills, repair costs, and lost wages out of pocket.
Lies are weapons in the legal system. If you don’t counter them effectively, you hand the other driver—and their insurer—all the power in your case.
How Lloyd Miller Law Group Uncovers the Truth in Car Accident Cases
Our Chicago accident lawyers are relentless in exposing lies and fighting for the truth. We use every available resource to build unassailable cases.
Immediate Action
- Demand and secure traffic cam footage before it disappears
- Interview witnesses while memories are fresh
- Photograph and document all evidence before it’s altered
- Consult with experts to preserve crucial data
Thorough Investigation
- Subpoena phone records to prove distracted driving
- Hire accident reconstruction experts for scientific analysis
- Obtain maintenance records and vehicle histories
- Review all available surveillance footage
Aggressive Legal Strategy
- Cross-examine witnesses to expose inconsistencies
- Present compelling evidence packages to insurance companies
- Prepare for trial when negotiations fail
- Hold lying drivers accountable through all legal means
Frequently Asked Questions About Drivers Lying After Car Accidents
Can a driver get away with lying about a car accident?
Not if you act fast and hire experienced legal representation. Lies can work in the short term, but with the right lawyer and evidence, they collapse under scrutiny.
What if the police believe the other driver’s story?
Police reports aren’t the final authority in determining fault. Your attorney can present evidence that corrects the record and proves actual liability.
Can I still win my case if it’s my word against theirs?
Absolutely. Modern accident cases rely on much more than competing statements. Photos, witnesses, camera footage, vehicle data, and expert testimony can all outweigh false statements.
Don’t Let a Liar Win. Call a Chicago Car Accident Lawyer Today
When the other driver lies, you need more than basic legal representation. You need an attorney who can uncover the truth about what caused your crash and hold dishonest drivers accountable. At Lloyd Miller Law Group, we’ve been battling dishonest drivers and greedy insurers for years—and we know how to win.
Our track record speaks for itself. We’ve recovered millions for clients who were initially blamed for accidents they didn’t cause. We know how to dismantle lies, expose perjury, and present compelling evidence that juries believe.
The clock is ticking. Evidence disappears, witnesses forget, and lies become harder to disprove with each passing day. Contact Lloyd Miller Law Group today and let us fight for the truth. Call us now at 773-838-8100 for a free consultation. We serve Chicago and all of Cook County, and we don’t charge any upfront fees. You only pay if we win your case.
